Monday, December 2, 2024
Luke 3:1-6
Summary: A familiar text with many preaching paths. Once again we need to head to the wilderness, the familiar cry of John the Baptist, to restore our sights. To put it another way, Advent remains a reason of repentance (whatever color we now use), but one where repentance isn't simply about personal sins, but a reorientation of our whole mind away from the crap out there about Christmas and toward the salvation of God unfolding in Jesus Christ.
Key words:
τετρααρχουντες ("rule as tetra-arch"; 3:1) The word tetra-arch means rule as a piddly regional governor. Luke includes a number of historical details in his Gospel, especially early on; Luke clearly wants to show that Jesus birth and life are actual events.
ρημα ("word"; 3:2) This word means "word." It will come into English the word "hermeneutic," i.e., the lens through which one looks at the data. This is really interesting to read John's work like this: "The hermeneutic of God came to John", which was forgiveness, baptism and repentance. What if our repentance means viewing life through this hermeneutic!
βαπτισμα ("baptism"; 3:3). Originally, this word did not have religious meaning. It simply meant to dip. For your enjoyment, here are the Liddell-Scott Hellenistic meanings of the word. Wow!
I. trans. to dip in water
2. to dip in poison
3. to dip in dye, to dye
4. to draw water
II. intransitive the ship dipped, ie, sank
Try preaching that: Baptism as a dip in poison; as a dip in dye; as a drawing of water from God; as finally, a sinking ship!
μετανοεω ("repent"; 3:3) The Greek meaning of the word is "new mind." In Liddell-Scott's ancient (and secular) Greek lexicon, "repent" means to change one's mind or purpose. We often put repentance together with sin, a fine thing, but perhaps we need to consider that repentance means often more than simply a struggle against temptation, but a paradigm shift, a transformation of our whole outlook, if not way of life and even being. In this case, there is a shift into the forgiveness of sins. Perhaps that is what Jesus ministry is really about, not simply our own forgiveness, but inculcating a world view that finally includes forgiveness. Perhaps this is σωτηριον (salvation): when the world finally embraces forgiveness as the path. Overarching point: μετανοεω in Greek and in the New Testament means far more than forgiveness of sins. (Or forgiveness of sins means far more than we think it does).
πληρωθησται (πληροω, fill or fulfill, 3:5) and ταπεινωθησται (ταπεινω, fulfill, 3:5): The English renders these words as "raised up" and "made low." Yet Luke (and Isaiah) use the words here for fill and humble. These then echo other parts of Luke's Gospel (the Magnificat; Jesus words on the road to Emmaus). These represent key features of Jesus mission: To fulfill and to humble.
Grammar note: Lack of punctuation in ancient languages
Original Hebrew and Greek manuscripts lack punctuation; it was added later by monks. So we really don't know if Isaiah meant, "A voice cries out, 'In the wilderness prepare the way of the Lord'" or "A voice cries out in the Wilderness, 'prepare the way of the Lord'." The monks thought the former...probably good to go with their instinct, especially given the need, in the Exile, to walk through the wilderness from Babylon to Israel. If this is the case, it seems that the Gospel writers change the punctuation to fit their own program of matching John's work with the description in Isaiah.
A few options: The scholarly one: Preach or teach, in a despising fashion, about how the NT abuses the OT
The Christological one: Preach and teach about how the NT rightfully abuses (reinterprets) the OT to make it fit with Christ!
Or the pastoral one: In this case both punctuation possibilities are valid. John the Baptist cries out in the wilderness. Yet he speaks to each of us to get into the wilderness, away from all the chaos of the world, to focus on God and God alone.
Monday, November 18, 2024
John 18:28-40 (John 18:33-37)
This passage occurs in the Narrative Lectionary Year 4 Lenten Cycle. A portion of this passage, John 18:33-37, appears in the Revised Common Lectionary for Christ the King Sunday.
Summary: Pilate's character in the Gospel of John is complex. It seems that John wants to drive home the point that not even Pilate is in control of the situation, but only Jesus. In John's Gospel, Jesus is never the one on trial; humanity is. Pilate's interview haunts us with the question: What is truth? The answer is obviously Jesus, but what does that mean? And yes, our answer should be slightly offensive. It got Jesus killed; it should at least get us in a little trouble.
Note for Christ the King Sunday: This is definitely a passage in which I would include vs 38 - "What is truth?"
μαρτυρεω ("testify", literally martyr, vs 18:37) This word means to give a witness, like in court. Jesus takes his place as the first Christian martyr, one who will be killed for the truth. So many Christians died giving their witness that the word's meaning changed.
βασιλευς ("king", vs. 18:33,37) BDAG define this as "One who rules as possessor of the highest office in a political realm." Already this shows Pilate considers the whole trial as a sham. Could Pilate really execute the king of the Jews? Obviously not.
ἠγωνίζοντο ("struggle" or "fight", from ἀγωνίζομαι, vs 36) Jesus says that his followers would be constantly fighting (ἠγωνίζοντο) if his kingdom were of this world.
- This brings into focus "Christ the King" Sunday. What does it mean for Jesus to be king?! Always a question. Many shy away from "Christ the King" Sunday because of its patriarchal overtones. Added to the church calendar in the 1920s, the Pope who installed it observed the many divisions and wanna-be kings. The Pope chose to lean into this framework and then undermine it be claiming Christ to be the true King. To that point, Jesus does not reject his kingship, he rejects Pilate's expectations that this brings with it violence. As Americans, we continue to hear and perhaps fear that our 2020s mirrors the 1920s in Germany, in which a (pseudo-)Christian nationalism arose. These verses open up a natural preaching door to reflecting on how (again and again) Christians reject the path of suffering and embrace the path of violence to achieve their ends. So - do you walk away from the image of Christ the King or live into it?
- The word literally means "agony." "If my kingdom were of this world, my followers would be agonizing." Are we as followers of Jesus not expected to have any agony? It seems that our life will have agony as we embrace the way of the cross...
κοσμος ("world", literally cosmos, vs 18:37) Just a reminder: God loves the world, but the world doesn't love back:
- It doesn't understand God (1:10)
- It doesn't give like God (14:27)
- In fact, it hates God (7:7).
αληθεια ("truth", vs 18:37,38) BDAG writes, "truth is a favorite word of the Johannine literature." Certainly is a core concept:
- John 1:17 The law came through Moses, but grace and truth came through Jesus
- John 17:17 God's word is truth
- John 14:6 Jesus is the truth
- John 16:13 Spirit leads to truth
- John 8:32 Truth sets on free
ληστης ("thief", vs. 40) The word means robber or "brigand" (a lovely word, right!). But Josephus, a Jewish historian writing during this time, always uses this word to mean social bandit/revolutionary. It clearly can mean this too. If you totally cannot focus on your sermon, you can read about what Josephus says about Jesus here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josephus_on_Jesus
Monday, November 11, 2024
Mark 13:1-8
This passage occurs in the Narrative Lectionary, along with Mark 13:24-37.
This passage occurs in the Revised Common Lectionary, year B (Most recently: Nov 2024)
Summary: If I had to preach this text, I would prefer to preach on vs. 13:9-11, which talks about the Spirit's work in and through the church between the first and second coming of Jesus. But hey, if 1-8 is what you have got, the Greek can still open up some fruitful preaching doors: First, what is the foundation of your life? And second, what is the destiny of life?
Two key insights:
λιθος ("stone", 13:1,2)
The NRSV translates the second half of verse 13:2 like almost every other translation:
"Not one stone will be left here upon another; all will be thrown down." However, the text literally reads:
"A stone here will never be permitted upon a stone, which will never be destroyed."
The NRSV translators take this to mean that every stone of this building will be destroyed. I think it means this, but I also think we can take Jesus a bit more literally at his words: These stones cannot be laid on the eternal rock, who is him.
You might say I am digging here, but consider Mark 12:10 -- Jesus refers to himself as the rejected stone which has become the cornerstone. Jesus builds on this earlier statement and says these stones no longer mean anything in light of him, who is the true and eternal temple.
The basic point, regardless of translation, is that in light of Jesus, the true temple and rock, this temple and rocks are unimportant, finally heretical. I just think we can safely add that Mark allows Jesus to refer to himself, subtly, as an eternal rock. Regardless, it brings us to the real helpful preaching point: What is the foundation in your life? For 1st century Jews, the temple would have been a foundation piece of their life, a center of mystery and meaning. Jesus says, this doesn't really matter, he does. Rather than critique first century Jews, we should ask ourselves: What idols -- even of our building spaces -- have we built for ourselves?
In fact, the disciples do not use an adjectives to describe the stones, although almost all of the translators use the words "large" or even "magnificent." The disciples use the word ποταπαι (13.1), which is a question word meaning: What kind of? or "Where are they from?" In short, they ask Jesus a deeper question -- what kind of temple is this in front of us? It is one made of human hands!
τελος ("end", 13:7)
The NIV translates the second half of verse 7 like almost every other translation
"Such things must happen, but the end is still to come."
A few other notes:
13:2 Jesus twice uses the emphatic "no" construction in Greek "ou mh" ου μη (ie never ain't gonna happen). This strong negative reinforces my previous argument that the old temple will not rest on the new temple, Jesus Christ. This is what Jesus says anyway, but the actual Greek reveals this in a subtle way.
13:1 The word for "building" here is "oikodomeh" οικοδομαι which can mean structure, but also edification or up-buidling. For example, Romans 14:19, "Let us pursue what leads to peace and the UPBUILDING of one another."
13:3 The phrase here in Greek to describe the disciples is "kata idian," translated "privately" (lit: according to their own). κατά ιδιαν This is used throughout the Gospel of Mark; this is the last time anything will be said privately though.
Monday, November 4, 2024
Mark 12:38-44
Summary: This is a case where the Greek does not alter the meaning, but simply forces us to slow down and examine Jesus' familiar words. Jesus offers a strident critique of an overly consuming, self-aggrandizing and elitist clergy. Yikes. More generally, I think Jesus makes a comment on how all of us consume and how we give.
βλεπω (12:38; "see") The word here for "watch out" is simply the Greek 101 for see; Jesus will tell his followers to "watch out" five times in this section (12:38, 13:5; 9; 23; 33).
γραμματευς (12:38; "scribes") This word has an obvious English cognate: "Grammar." The question for us today is, whom do we need to watch out for -- who are the grammarians today? I struggle with this question a bit more personally -- how do I become a grammarian, who says "no" to the working of the Lord, either in my congregation or in my denomination? How do I NOT become someone whom Jesus warns against. The further description of Jesus' critique includes:
they wear στολη (12:38, "stole" or "robe")
and sit in the
προτοκαθεδρια (12:39, "first seat"). Ouch.
κατεσθιω (12:40, "devour") As you guessed, the Bible uses this word in an entirely negative fashion. It also comes up in the prodigal son, where the son has consumed the father's property (literally, βιος, used also in this passage in vs. 44). One can read this passage as a narrow critique of 1st century Jewish leadership, more broadly of religious leaders over time, or most broadly, against all over-consumption. In what ways does our whole culture "devour widows houses while praying long prayers." A prophetic voice is helpful and perhaps here, but how can this be done so that its not simply an attack on others (or in an election year, people who voted differently), but a call for all of us to repent?
βιος (12:44, "life" The woman gives "the whole of her life" The word life here is "bios." So the sermon is not about stewardship of money, but stewardship of everything.
Grammar note: Here we have a substantive participle "the ones who devour" followed by a participle "praying." There are a couple of ways these two participles (devouring and praying) could be related. I think the best way to translate the participle "praying" is as a circumstantial participle: "the ones who devour widows houses while praying long prayers." Ouch! They pray while they sin.
Sunday, October 20, 2024
Mark 10:46-52
This passage occurs in both the Revised Common Lectionary Year B and the Narrative Lectionary Year B. (Most recently Oct 27, 2024.)
Note on Reformation Day and this passage
This passage will sometimes occur on the same Sunday as Reformation Day, a day when Lutheran churches and others often use John 8 (here is my commentary on this passage) . Even when not on Reformation Day, it might make a very good text for a sermon on the Reformation. You have a man crying out for mercy (Luther's search); a religious crowd opposed to him (sinful self and world); a display of Jesus compassion; Jesus' Word giving life; Proclamation that faith saves; lastly, new life in following Christ.
To review:
Salvation, even new creation, by faith alone
The mercy of Christ
The sinfulness of the world, even in religious matters
The redeeming Word
Or John 8, with landmines of antisemitism. You make the call...
Words I found interesting
οδος ("road" or "way", from οδος, vs. 46) This word has layers of meanings. It is one of those words that can simply mean "path for travel" but more abstractly "way"." Early Christians were called followers of "The Way." In Mark 8, 9, and 10, Jesus has been on the way. This journey in Mark is about spiritual blindness and sight. It begins with a blind man needing healing; the stories display how the disciples are blind to Jesus power; it ends with blind Bartimeaus receiving sight. It points toward the reality that any talk about spiritual journey without struggle, sin and setback is nonsense!
Βαρτιμαιος ("Son of honor", 46) We don't know many names of those cured by Jesus, but this one has a name -- Son of honor. In this case, the son of honor is banished by the crowd, mocked and insulted. Perhaps this is foreshadowing of Jesus, the true son of Honor, being mocked by the crowd. Furthermore, it is ironic that James and John, the sons of Zebedee, ask for power and get the cross. This man calls out for mercy and gets resurrection. "Afflict the comforted and comfort the afflicted"
εκπορευομενου ("go out", 46) Jesus is heading out of town, but a call for mercy changes his plans. When is the last time a call for mercy changed your plans? Jesus seems always to find time for compassion.
ελεησον ("mercy", from ελεεω, 48) A key feature of Martin Luther's journey was the search for mercy. It certainly is what Christ has come to bring. Is this what people hunger for today?
κραζον ("cry", 48) Also worth noting is that the man is crying (κραζον) out. The verb is transliterated "crazied." Also, the verb is in the imperfect tense, indicating this is an on-going action. Mark is painting a vivid picture here of suffering and lament.
στας ("stand", 49) For the first and only time in Mark's Gospel, Jesus stands still. He takes a pause from the journey on the road to have compassion on this man. The story pivots on Jesus' action here (you could even do a need chaistic structure within the story with this as the fulcrum). It is worth remembering about this story and really the whole Reformation, that Jesus' love and compassion are at the center.
θαρσει ("take courage", 49) This word can also mean "be audacious." Christ is calling us to follow him, over and against the cries of the world.
εγειρε ("raise" or "resurrect", 49) Jesus has been proclaiming his eventual resurrection. Now the resurrection is happening -- the kingdom of God unfolding in our midst. What makes it possible? The voice of Jesus -- the word of God.
αποβαλων (participle of απο-βαλλω, 50) The man has to throw something away -- to take something off -- in order to follow Jesus. What must we give up to follow Jesus? There is a risk in following our Lord; a willingness to get it wrong! This is something I am thinking about a lot as a middle aged man. We get so comfortable and set in our ways, that we lose sight of the fact that Jesus calls us again and again to follow him, even when this means getting it wrong and taking risks.
ιματον ("garment", 50) The word ιματον will come up again the rest of Mark's Gospel. The people will again take off their cloaks/coats for Jesus in his triumphal entry/Palm procession (next chapter); then they will put a pretend garment on Jesus to mock him; and they will cast lots for his garment. You could say that Blind Bartimeaus is the first one to celebrate Palm Sunday :-)
αναπηδησας ("jump up", 50) The man jumps up. Mark, again, is creating is a vivid scene full of motion. What is fascinating to consider is that man who jumps up and is walking is still blind. Faith may lead to sight, but sometimes we are called simply to move...Ie, part of the journey of faith may not have as much a sight as we would like. I reflect on Luther's own journey...and the journey of myself and others...where sometimes we sense God calling us but we don't yet see the light!
σεσωκεν ("save", from σωζω 52) This word refers to both "earthly" salvation as well as heavenly. Explosive term. It can meal heal, but also save. But basic point here: Salvation is not simply about the afterlife, but life in Christ, which is everlasting.
Monday, October 14, 2024
Mark 10:35-45
This passage is found in the Revised Common Lectionary Year B (Most recently Oct 20, 2024)
Summary: Don't get too lost in the Greek in this week's passage. The point is that two key disciples are asking really silly questions. It proves Jesus an opportunity to say to them directly what he has been suggesting to them all along: While they do not need to be crucified, to be a follower of Jesus means following him to the cross, to the suffering of the world, to the surrender of our will and to the death of sinner. I focus a fair amount on the word "ransom," hopefully opening a different way of thinking about this.
ποτηριον ("poterion" (pottery!), meaning "cup", 10:38) There are three cups in Mark's Gospel! Can you name them? The first is when Jesus says the one giving a glass of cold water will not lose their reward (9:41). The second is here. The third is the communion cup. The cup which Jesus refers to here is following Christ. This seems to be a good sermon, something like: The first cup of discipleship is doing small things for others; the second cup is living/giving of our whole life; the third is receiving communion with Christ, as he comes to forgive us. As Luther says in the small catechism: All this he did that I may be his own.
βαπτίζομαι vs βαπτισθηαι ("baptize", 10:38) I want to point out a distinction in verb tenses here. When Jesus refers to the baptism of the disciples, he uses the aorist tense, suggesting a one-time event. When Jesus refers to his own baptism, he uses the present tense, suggesting an on-going and present event. Jesus literally says, "which I am being baptized right now"; he is in the midst of his baptism as he begins his long road to the cross. Our Baptism may be a one time event, but living out of our baptism is an on-going process.
κατακυριευουσιν ("literally over-lord", 10:42) Just a little note for preachers personally rather than for a sermon. This verb shows up rarely in the New Testament, but it does show up in 1 Peter 5:3, as an admonishment to pastors not to Lord over their power!
οι δοκουντες ("the ones who think", 10:42) Jesus does not say the rulers actually rule. He says the think or seem.
[Really geeky thought: For those paying a bit more attention, this is the same word 'seem' (δοκεω) that was used to describe a group of chief early heretics: the Docetics, who said that Jesus only "seemed" to die.)
δουλος ("servant" or "slave", 10:44) This word appears repeatedly in the New Testament as a model for Christian life and service. As the Thayer Greek Lexicon reminds us, δουλος του χριστου (servants of Christ) are those whose service is used by Christ in extending and advancing his cause among [others]: used of apostles, Rom. 1:1; Gal. 1:10; Phil. 1:1; 2 Tim. 2:24; Titus 1:1; James 1:1; 2 Pet. 1:1; of other preachers and teachers of the gospel, Col. 4:12; 2 Tim. 2:24; Jude 1:1; of the true worshipers of Christ.
Do we articulate, model and challenge our people enough to adopt a posture of servant-hood?
λυτρον ("redemption", 10:45). This word is a loaded term. It is often suggested that Jesus was the ransom whose death serves as the payment rendered for our sins, thus freeing us from this deserved punishment. Both Exodus 21:30, 30:12 convey this sense of λυτρον. I am not going to argue here against substitutionary atonement.
However, the Old Testament also puts forward another sense of λυτρον that I think works just as well, if not better, in this case. In Numbers 3, there is the (for most of us) relatively unknown story of the consecration of the Levites to the priesthood and how they are offered as a redemption (λυτρον). A surprisingly helpful commentary summarized the logic:
"...when God slew the first born of man and beast among the Egyptians, he consecrated the first-born of Israel to himself as a memorial of the deliverance. First-born animals were to be sacrificed to the Lord, but first-born sons were to be redeemed by the substitution of a payment of money. Now the Levites are taken by the Lord as the redemption of all the first-born males in Israel, and their very office becomes a perpetual sign of Israel's deliverance. The ministry of the Levites proclaimed to Israel the fact that all belong to the Lord, because he has delivered them. (75, Mays; 1963 Layman's Bible Commentary.")
In short, in the consecration of the Levites, God turns the sacrificial system on its head. God does not want sacrifices of first-born humans (and never did), rather, God wants the Levites to take the place of the first-born, not for death, but for service to God.
I am still fleshing this out, but I think you can make the argument that "ransom" can be utilized in a way where Jesus frees us to serve God without needing God to be angry with Jesus.
Perhaps it is something like this: Jesus is put forward as a ransom, but not simply for death, but for service to God. What God wants - in the ransom sense - is not the death of Jesus, but the life, the service (which in his case, will include death). As we are baptized into Jesus' death and drink his cup, we too are put forward, not as a substitute punishment, but as something precious to God, namely, servants of God, becoming the new priesthood, in fact, a very proclamation that the Lord has delivered us.
Monday, October 7, 2024
Mark 10:17-31
This passage is found in the Revised Common Lectionary Year B after Pentecost (Most recently October 13, 2024)
Summary: "Clouded up" -- That is literally the words used to describe the rich young man's reaction to Jesus. Jesus loves the man, but the man's love of his possessions obscure his vision so greatly, he cannot even embrace the love of God! We may not be able to buy our way into heaven but today's passage suggests we can buy our way out of heaven!
Some words that might open preaching possibilities:
[added 2024] προσδραμὼν ("run" or "exert", form of προστρέχω; 10.17) The man is running to Jesus. This can be seen in a positive light -- the man is eager to meet Jesus. It can also be seen as "busy man", the person always moving, always climbing, yet not getting anywhere.
ζωην αιωνουν ("life eternal"; zoo of the eons, literally; 10.17 and 30): It is interesting that eternal life enters into Mark's Gospel by way of a non-disciple (and practicing Jew). Obviously this appears in John's Gospel numerous times, but makes a cameo or two in the other Gospels as well. Perhaps one of the great misnomers of Christian thinking is that eternal life only begins after our physical death. The love and fellowship of Jesus was available here, on earth, for the man (see note below).
κληρονoησω ("inherit"; 10:17): The man may not understand that eternal life is a gift, but he does understand one thing: it is going to take a death to bring about life -- you only get the inheritance when someone dies!
αποστερεω ("defraud"; 10:19) The NET Bible suggests Jesus inserts this because of the OT's injunctions about this, for example, Deut 24:14. I would maintain that the word defraud is not accidental, but a great insight into the text. Jesus adds this commandment because he knows the rich young man is guilty of it -- the 11th commandment! As my internship pastor preached on this passage -- what is the commandment that finally trips you or me up?? I don't murder...but what finally brings me to my knees in confession?
αγαπαω ("love"; 10.21) This word means real, genuine, nearly, if not truly, divine love. This man is the first one whom Jesus loves in the whole Gospel of Mark! How sad then that the man cannot love Jesus back nor follow him!
κτημα ("possessions"; 10:22) Our American context is very different than ancient Greece, where a very small number owned most things. Yes, yes, the rich grow richer, but the average American still has enough possessions and toys at their disposal to last them for years. We can make this passage about demonizing the truly wealthy, or realize the nature of our own possessions that cloud our own vision. Side note: The NET Bible
στυγναζω ("sad" or "cloud up"; 10.23): The word for "sad" here is a less common Greek word, but it means gloomy, or clouded over, like the sky. The man's love of possessions cloud up his vision.
τεκνα ("children", 10.24). Right after Jesus has told them they must accept the kingdom as a child, he calls them children. Perhaps a sign of love? Perhaps a call to humility? I think it is fair to say that, at least within Mark's Gospel, the driving point is that the only way into the Kingdom is to realize we cannot get there out of our own power, as a child!
Jesus can both εμβλεπω (in-look) (vs. 21, 27) and περιβλεπω (around-look) (vs. 23). In short, Jesus has insight (literally) and around sight (literally). Jesus can both look into people but also take a step back and look at the situation. A rare skill.
Subjunctive mood:
The subjunctive mood, which Greek uses to indicate various hypothetical situations, is difficult to translate. In 10.17 we find the filled-with-subjunctive phrase "What must I do to inherit eternal life?" The Greek does not use the word "must" but simply uses the subjunctive mood. Luther's German translation, "What should I do" is probably a better understanding of what is meant here.
Imperfect tense:
The imperfect tense suggests repeated action. In 10.17 The rich young man does not "ask" but in fact "asks," repeatedly -- the imperfect tense is used. He really wants to know!
Future as perfect tense?
In 10.30, Jesus talks about the age "that is coming." It is not "the age that came" or the "age that will come" or even "the age to come" but "the age that is coming." Greek, like English, can use the present to suggest an indeterminate future. "Coming" can mean "on the way" or "coming soon." There is an ambiguity. So the question is, does the eternal life age arrive after we die or while we live? It seems that Jesus is referring to a pre-natural death event...but perhaps one that requires our spiritual death and resurrection.